I fell in love with comp climbing after seeing a video of Alex Puccio dominate at the 2011 National Championship. My eyes were glued to my computer screen as I watched her stick the crux of the final boulder problem. She held her composure as the crowd roared and the announcers screamed "ALEX PUCCIO IS FROM ANOTHER PLANET". Almost giddy, I jumped up and did a little dance for the reigning National Champion. It was at that moment that I knew competition climbing was all I wanted to do. From then on, I knew exactly what I wanted to be.
And so, I was raised a comp climber.
My climbing days were spent running grueling power-endurance exercises, and my exposure to nature was often limited to a glance at the moon on my way home from late practice. I know for the veterans, my type of climbing sounds unpleasing, maybe even miserable. For me though, I never had interest in anything else. I was part of a new generation of athletes- the ones who would prefer a day of rigorous training to a day spent in nature in hopes of eventually standing on top of a podium.
There's a funny thing about trying to become the best climber though. Maybe its ignorance or unfamiliarity, but I have always found it much more difficult to quantify ability in climbing than in any other individual sports. In running, you can time who is the fastest; in javelin, you can check who throws the farthest; in gymnastics, you can see who hits each of their previously-memorized marks. Yet in climbing, we try to decide who is the best simply through a series of unknown, and relatively untested "problems". With talent at an all-time high, it is not unlikely that the most powerful climber loses because he cannot complete the slab wall, or the highly favored competitor gets shut down by a dyno on her very first climb. To these scenarios, it would seem that being the most well-rounded athlete is the clearest solution. Yet, this can also be problematic. When a "well-rounded" climber does well on each problem but fails to get a top, it is likely that he will find himself trailing behind the specialists.
It is for this reason that finding the "best" rock climber is so difficult, for the most burly climber, the most balanced climber, and the most crafty climber is very rarely the same person. Obviously there are patterns, and we generally see the stronger competitors finish around the same spot. Yet, if we were to run a competition with the top-tier athletes 3 times with 3 different sets of routes, the likelihood that the results would stay consistent is little to none.
That is why I think competitions do not aim to find the order of climbing ability amongst athletes, but rather the order of ability given the day and given the particular routes. There are no guarantees in any sporting event, but I think in climbing particularly, certainty is even harder to find.
Over the last couple years, I have found myself standing in the majority of the places in the top 10- its been an ongoing joke that someday I might collect every medals to complete the set. That is not to say that my ability or my training has varied from competition to competition. On the contrary, I think the only thing that ever really varies is the route I am given. As a competitor, it is difficult to rationalize training for a single event when so many variables seem "up in the air". I guess the fault in being strictly a comp climber lies in the uncertainty of victory, and the unwavering fear that despite countless hours of preparation, results are very dependent on the problems and how we solve them.
So is competition climbing here to stay? Who knows. Sometimes I am skeptical that it is possible to find the best climber through such a fleeting trial. Climbing's facets are hard to judge, and even harder to compare amongst high-level competitors. For an athlete, this means training your hardest and hoping the cards lay in your favor. For a spectator, this means that you may not know on who you should bet. And, for the very few who transcend the uncertainty to consistently dominate their field, this means that eating your Wheaties has definitely been working.